Tuesday, 28 January 2014

Leading a Journal Club

Leading a Journal Club

Why lead a journal club meeting?
●                  It's a great way of having everyone get to know you.
●                  It's fun (speaking from personal experience).
●                  It gives you an opportunity to read something that you wouldn't otherwise devote the time to. Maybe something outside your field.
●                  It can give you the opportunity to get feedback and perspective about a paper that you are using in your own research. Maybe a pivotal paper in your literature review.
●                  It's a great opportunity to practise your professional skills like public speaking, summarising content and critical analysis. And you can do this all in a supportive and casual setting.
●                  That warm fuzzy feeling that you get from doing something nice that you don't have to do!
Step 1: Choose your meeting
There's a link to the schedule from this page: http://parkville-bioinformatics-journal-club.blogspot.com.au/ (top right corner)
Step 2: Choose your paper(s)
You would usually choose one or two papers. If one of the papers is quite domain specific you may like to choose a review paper as well to introduce people to the topic.
Step 3: Advertise your meeting
About a week before the meeting send the paper reference(s) to the group along the with the PDF and/or any relevant links. It also might be nice to explain briefly why you chose the paper(s). You can do this yourself via the mailing list, or send the details to the organisers and they will sort it out.
Step 4: Print the paper(s)
Come with a few print outs of the paper if possible. Usually about half the people print their own, so 4 or 5 copies is usually plenty.
Step 5: Summarise the paper(s)
Give a brief verbal summary of what the paper was about. Aim for about 5 mins. Think of this as a verbal abstract, but with perhaps even less detail. The idea is to give people who haven't read it a basic idea of what the paper was about.
You may want to finish with a comment about what you thought of the paper. What were it's strengths and weaknesses? Why did you choose it?
Step 5: Note some conversation topics
Note down a few questions or comments that came up for you when you were reading the paper. This way if the conversation lags you will have some things to bring up.
On the day:
These times are a guide only to give you and idea of what to expect. If you are leading the group, you are in charge, so feel free to work at your own pace.
7:55am Leader attempts to get there first and claim the big table at Dr Dax. 8:00am People start arriving and order coffee/breakfast. Keep an eye out for new members. They will be lurking, looking uncertainly at groups of people.
8:10am Consider doing a round of introductions, particularly if there are new members. Hand out printed papers as needed.
8:15am Leader gives a quick summary of the paper and then opens the discussion up to the group. If the conversation lags the leader should bring up one of their questions/points about the paper.
8:50am Round up the discussion. Check when the next meeting is and who is speaking (or ask for a volunteer).
Optional: Write a short blog post
If you're really keen, and you want to get even more professional development out the experience, you might consider writing a blog post. You can write about whatever you like and/or reuse your notes from the meeting.

Most of all, remember to enjoy yourself. This is not a formal presentation. No one is judging you. We are just a group of newbies trying to make sense of the field.