To kick off 2015, the theme of yesterday's Journal Club was about increasing academic productivity. Two blog posts dealt with effective annual goal setting and "New Year's resolutions for scientists". Although interesting and full of useful ideas, these were rather uncontentious.
In contrast, some rather impassioned discussion was – perhaps predictably – inspired by an article in PLOS ONE with the understated title of An Efficiency Comparison of Document Preparation Systems Used in Academic Research and Development.
From the moment it was first published about a month ago, this article has been generating a lot of heated internet discussion. Both the comments section and the media coverage page reveal widespread indignation and scoffing. The authors have also made an extensive comment in which they answer some of the objections. (I'll keep referring to this as the response.)
The discussion around our Journal Club breakfast table went on to mirror the same debate. Fortunately we're all friends so we managed to avoid taking it out onto the streets in full blown internecine warfare; although, it was close!
Concisely, Knauff & Nejasmic set up a study comparing LaTeX to Microsoft Word and their conclusion favours the latter for most tasks. The article has been criticised because of biases in the study design, and because its discussion takes results from this study and escalates to some strong assertions. Effectively, the authors proscribe the use of LaTeX except in certain circumstances; furthermore, they impugn the judgement of LaTeX users, not only in the article per se but again in their response to comments.
Since these criticisms can be found by going to the comments and media coverage sections linked above, there'll be little need to repeat them here. The intent here will be to focus on something that doesn't seem to have been targeted by many other comments or blog posts. This is, that the authors clearly feel entitled by their psychological training to make assumptions about their opponents' intellectual faculties. They do this without referring to any criteria of evidence. Their basis for measuring cognitive impairment is whether or not people agree with their conclusions.
Both article and response ring with cries of "cognitive dissonance"; and whereas the article attempts to justify its proscriptions by invoking "the taxpayer", that eternal hired thug of anti-intellectualism, the response more clearly reveals the authors' biases against LaTeX. The response is quite telling in the way the authors offer a blanket psychological assessment gratis to people who enjoy using LaTeX.
Namely, if you think it's important to keep content and structure separate to formatting instructions, then you are suffering under some colossal convergence not only of "cognitive dissonance" but now also "signalling" and "polarisation", with a bit of confirmation bias thrown in, oh my. This cutting analysis is mainly focused at LaTeX users, but they don't hesitate to advertise how they "think" that markdown "probably" shares many of the same problems.
Now, the authors belong to the Department of Psychology, Experimental Psychology and Cognitive Science at the University of Giessen. We can suppose, then, that they are psychologists. Maybe I'm suffering a bit of cognitive dissonance here, but I'm under the impression that psychologists would not consider themselves in a position to make sweeping statements about a diverse group of people without first conducting a study to investigate that group.
Note that this wouldn't be the same study as the one they've already undertaken, which was (ostensibly) concerned only with productivity differences between LaTeX and Word. In order to make broad assertions that LaTeX users suffer from cognitive dissonance and confirmation bias, reinforced by signalling and polarisation, then a study would need to be conducted on LaTeX users to see whether this characterisation has any basis in reality whatsoever.
Furthermore, by summoning forth all these psychological demons to support their overstretched assertions, do they not risk hoisting themselves by their own petards? For making guesses about other people's cognitive dissonances, confirmation biases, signalling and polarisation is a saloon door that can hit someone on the rear both while entering and leaving premises of ill repute.
After all, it's quite clear that Knauff & Nejasmic are indeed suffering, you guessed it, cognitive dissonance, confirmation bias, signalling and polarisation.
Cognitive dissonance: there is a disparity between the authors' scientific training and their jumping to conclusions based on biased study design. When this is brought to their attention, they attempt to reduce dissonance with unsatisfactory justifications (i.e. intensifying their poor arguments about LaTeX users' poor cognitive abilities), and by ignoring conflicting information ("Do we compare apples and oranges? We think that is just verbal hairsplitting ...").
Confirmation bias: this has been dealt with by those who have criticised the study's design, and the jump from the numerical results to wide-reaching conclusions. Furthermore, the response concludes with weasel words that strongly indicate their pre-existing bias: "in our group nobody uses LaTeX anymore since an efficient way of collaborating in the same document is more important to us than individual software preferences."
In other words, their group had already reached the conclusion that they don't like LaTeX. And if they began with a mixed group that became anti-LaTeX only after running the study, it seems unlikely that they would have failed to mention this. This implies that they had an anti-LaTeX group all along. So, the study concluding that LaTeX is usually inferior was designed and run by a group that had already decided without a study that LaTeX is inferior. Bias confirmed: check.
Signalling: if anything, this is the weakest argument against LaTeX. Humans signal all the time; it's part of being a social organism. If people in STEM didn't use LaTeX to signal, we'd still have the many other cool things which separates us from lesser mortals, such as version controlling everything and using the Unix command line for everything. I don't have a problem with the idea that LaTeX is a form of signalling because the signalling arises from its usefulness to a certain kind of person. My kind of person.
But if we want to use signalling as a basis for discrediting people, then it seems a little disingenuous of Knauff & Nejasmic to pretend that they're not also sending out signals. What better way to signal your cool contempt for a vast number of uptight math/computer nerds than publish an article calling for the banning of a beloved and venerable tool such as LaTeX? And should people on both sides of the debate stop publishing articles because this is a way to signal status in academia?
Polarisation: the thing with polarisation is that it needs two polar opposites to play off against each other. In psychology, polarisation is driven by a mechanism called the "pendulum effect". This requires two groups of people to make increasingly antagonistic statements towards each other. It doesn't work with just one group who have no one to argue against.
The only way polarisation could be responsible for generating a vocal LaTeX community is if LaTeX users have found themselves in arguments against people who are anti-LaTeX. That is, Knauff & Nejasmic, and their group, being anti-LaTeX, are in fact as much the victims of polarisation as their pro-LaTeX critics. What's more, if they take polarisation seriously, then it would behove them to take responsibility for driving the pendulum ever harder with their anti-LaTeX biases and extreme conclusions.
Overall, there is a twin problem with this psychological line of argument that Knauff & Nejasmic seem committed to. First of all, if the same argument can be used to win a debate in either direction, then you should probably be cautious about relying on it.
Secondly, and I think more importantly, it seems unethical for psychologists to carelessly diagnose all comers as having cognitive defects, with no burden of proof required, just for the purpose of point-scoring in an argument. I would hope at the very least that Knauff & Nejasmic will concede that this kind of behaviour has been inappropriate. They have an opportunity now to demonstrate their graciousness by apologising to LaTeX users for the numerous insults, and retracting their offensive and ill-conceived judgements.
Well, since we seem to be operating in a post-scientific wasteland where unsupported assertions are fine so long as no taxpayers are having their minds stretched, it must be safe to conclude with this xkcd which was not created using any taxpayer money:
NB: if you found all this annoying and your primate brain chemicals are urging you to flame someone, you may cross swords with me on twitter.

