tl;dr - Announcing:
- the publication of "Ten Simple Rules for a Bioinformatics Journal Club"
- the launch of the Journal Club Adventures comics
It is with some relief that the second article to come out of the Parkville Bioinformatics Journal Club has been published": "Ten Simple Rules for a Bioinformatics Journal Club".
Relief because we actually began this article almost two years ago in 2014! We had just studied the Ten Simple Rules collection as part of journal club, and thought it would be fun to write one ourselves.
During the early writing sessions for this idea, where we outlined things that we thought made the journal club a success, Harriet Dashnow made the offhand comment that it would be much easier to write Ten Simple Rules for Journal Club if there were a "Ten Simple Rules for Writing a PLOS Ten Simple Rules Article". That comment quickly escalated! (and distracted us for a few months).
Following the publication of that paper, and as the Journal Club continued to run in 2014, we returned to our first manuscript. Earlier versions of some of the rules were presented as a poster at the Australian Bioinformatics Conference (ABiC2014). It was at this point the conceit of including XKCD-style comics (thanks to the fantastic tool at http://cmx.io) was formed. We literally began by mocking up these comics on the backs of napkins (and HD may have adapted some XKCD comics in PowerPoint... because that's how science figures are done, right?).
![]() |
| Before http://CMX.io |
| After! |
We chipped away, and invited a few more authors to contribute to "Ten Simple Rules for a Bioinformatics Journal Club". Editing the text and going through several revisions (major and minor) took the better part of a year, mostly because this is a #sideproject, and contributions take place in the early mornings (during Writing Gym), late evenings and in the procrastination breaks that everyone has.
Note that even the most irreverent articles like these are peer reviewed, with the associated responses to comments, manuscript changes requested by editors and formatting requirements. As early-career researchers, it has been an invaluable experience.
One benefit of the long preparation was that as the journal club continued, we had more experiences to draw upon and the manuscript subsequently improved. It's been a fun experience, despite the long time from idea to publication. Thanks to all the other authors for their perseverance and hard work: Jocelyn, Michael and Tim.
Another silver lining is in that all that time, another idea has had time to develop and take shape in the background: Journal Club Adventures.
A few spurts of activity during that year of development, and time to think about how it could be done well using existing resources, resulted in a quick implementation that heavily leverages the original http://cmx.io. This design may change, but for a first attempt, it's functional and hopefully fun.
The origin of the comic itself is explained in adventure #0, and is setup to capture the same spirit of the Journal Club: a collaborative vehicle that we can use to show the lighter side of science and the community we've created that continues meets regularly at the uncivilised time of 8am.
Thanks for the ride!
Andrew and Harriet
@lonsbio @hdashnow
![]() |
| More comics will appear at Journal Club Adventures - https://journal-club-adventures.github.io |

